The Pittsburgh Pirates are focusing on player developments and administrative decisions as the offseason approaches. With several key players eligible for arbitration and promising rookies making their mark, the franchise is at a crucial juncture for its future.
Arbitration Eligibility and Salary Projections
As the offseason looms, the Pirates face important decisions regarding nine arbitration-eligible players. Among these, center fielder Oneil Cruz stands out, expected to receive the highest salary due to his pivotal role in the team's lineup. The team will need to weigh the potential raises against their budget as they strategize for the 2026 season. This is particularly pressing given the Pirates' challenging 2025 season, where they finished with a 71-91 record, the worst in the National League Central.
Rising Stars: Rookie Pitchers Shine
The Pirates had notable rookie performances this past season, particularly from pitchers Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson. Both players earned spots on Bleacher Report's list of top 50 rookies in the MLB, with Ashcraft ranking at No. 26 and Mattson at No. 46. Ashcraft made his debut on May 26 and quickly established himself as a key asset, while Mattson excelled in a higher-leverage role after the team traded closer David Bednar. The duo's impressive statistics—Mattson with a 2.45 ERA over 47.2 innings and Ashcraft demonstrating solid strikeout capabilities—offer a glimmer of hope for the Pirates' pitching future.
McCutchen's Future and Team Direction
Amidst the focus on younger players, the future of veteran Andrew McCutchen remains a hot topic. Discussions continue regarding whether the beloved outfielder will return for another season with the Pirates, as fans and analysts debate the pros and cons. His experience could be invaluable for the development of younger players, but the franchise also needs to consider long-term strategies as they build for success.
With the Pirates' recent struggles, including a managerial change earlier in the season, the organization is keen on restoring competitiveness. The upcoming offseason will be critical, not only for navigating arbitration but also for leveraging the potential of their rookie talent.
TL;DR
- The Pittsburgh Pirates have nine players eligible for arbitration this offseason, with Oneil Cruz expected to receive a significant raise.
- Rookie pitchers Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson earned recognition as some of the top newcomers in the MLB during the 2025 season.
- Andrew McCutchen's future with the Pirates remains uncertain as the team looks to balance veteran presence with younger talent.
- The organization is at a pivotal moment, needing to make strategic decisions to improve upon a disappointing 71-91 record in 2025.