The Pittsburgh Pirates are gearing up for an offseason filled with critical decisions regarding player contracts and potential roster changes. With nine players eligible for arbitration, including standout center fielder Oneil Cruz, the organization faces crucial financial considerations as they look to improve after a lackluster 2025 season.
Arbitration and Contract Decisions
The Pirates' arbitration-eligible players include some key contributors from the past season. Oneil Cruz stands out as the most notable among them, expected to command a significant salary increase after a productive year. As the Pirates evaluate their roster, discussions surrounding non-tender candidates are also gaining traction. This highlights the team's need to balance financial responsibilities with the goal of enhancing competitive performance.
General Manager Ben Cherington's decisions will be under scrutiny as fans and analysts alike ponder the future of the club's most recognized talent. With Cruz leading the charge, the Pirates aim to ensure that they retain their young stars while also addressing other areas of need.
Promising Rookies Shine
Amid ongoing contract deliberations, the Pirates can take solace in the emergence of their rookie pitching talent. Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson have both been recognized for their impressive performances in 2025, earning spots in the top 50 rookie rankings. Ashcraft debuted with the Pirates on May 26 and quickly established himself, showcasing his potential with a 2.45 ERA over 47.2 innings pitched. Mattson, who stepped into a critical role following a trade deadline deal, also finished strong, contributing significantly to the pitching staff.
Their successes provide a glimpse of hope for the Pirates as they look to rebuild and develop a more competitive roster moving forward. The development of young pitchers like Ashcraft and Mattson could be pivotal as management looks to improve the team's overall performance.
McCutchen's Future in Question
One of the most pressing narratives surrounding the Pirates is the future of veteran outfielder Andrew McCutchen. As a beloved figure in Pittsburgh, McCutchen's next steps will significantly impact the team's identity. While some argue for his continued presence as a mentor to younger players, others suggest it might be time to make room for a fresh wave of talent. The organization must weigh these considerations as they navigate the offseason.
As the Pirates prepare for 2026, the interplay between retaining established players and fostering new talent will be critical. Decisions made in the coming weeks will shape not only the immediate future of the team but also its long-term trajectory.
TL;DR
- The Pittsburgh Pirates have nine players eligible for arbitration, including key player Oneil Cruz.
- Rising stars Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson have gained recognition as top rookies after solid performances in 2025.
- Andrew McCutchen’s future with the team remains uncertain, with discussions about his role as a mentor versus a potential departure.
- The Pirates must balance contract negotiations with the goal of enhancing their competitive roster for the upcoming season.