The Pittsburgh Pirates are navigating a critical offseason filled with player evaluations as they prepare for the 2026 season. With numerous arbitration-eligible players and promising rookie performances, the franchise looks to reshape its roster amidst challenges from the previous season.
Arbitration and Player Contracts
As the offseason approaches, the Pirates face significant decisions regarding their nine arbitration-eligible players. Among the most notable is center fielder Oneil Cruz, who is projected to command the highest salary based on his performance and potential. The team must weigh the benefits of retaining key players against the risks of non-tendering some, a strategy that could reshape the roster as they seek to improve upon their last-place finish in the National League Central.
The Pirates' 2025 season ended with a disappointing 71-91 record, prompting speculation about future roster moves as they aim to break a decade-long playoff drought. The front office is under pressure to make prudent decisions that will enhance team competitiveness in the upcoming season.
Rising Stars in the Spotlight
While the Pirates grapple with contract decisions, they can take solace in the emergence of young talent. Two rookie pitchers, Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson, have garnered attention for their impressive performances, landing them spots on Bleacher Report's list of top MLB rookies for 2025. Ashcraft, who debuted on May 26, showcased his potential with a solid record and a strong strikeout-to-walk ratio. Meanwhile, Mattson stepped up in a higher-leverage role after the trade of closer David Bednar and finished the season with a commendable 2.45 ERA over 47.2 innings.
This focus on developing young players is crucial for the Pirates as they work to build a sustainable competitive team. Paul Skenes, another standout pitcher for the Pirates, was recently named Baseball Digest's Pitcher of the Year, further highlighting the franchise's promising young arms.
Future Outlook
The Pirates' management is aware that significant changes are necessary to improve their standing in the league. Analysts suggest that addressing the roster's weaknesses through strategic trades and draft selections will be essential. The upcoming 2026 MLB Draft holds potential for the Pirates, as they are projected to select a top talent, with mock drafts suggesting the team may target a standout shortstop from Alabama.
As the offseason unfolds, the Pirates must balance player development, contract negotiations, and roster adjustments to build a more competitive squad. The pressure is on management to make the right decisions that could finally lead to a return to postseason baseball.
TL;DR
- The Pirates face key decisions regarding nine arbitration-eligible players, including star center fielder Oneil Cruz.
- Rookie pitchers Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson have emerged as promising talents, earning recognition among MLB's top rookies.
- Paul Skenes was named Baseball Digest's Pitcher of the Year, showcasing the strength of the Pirates' young arms.
- The 2026 MLB Draft presents an opportunity for the Pirates to select top talent and reshape their roster moving forward.