The Pittsburgh Pirates are navigating a crucial offseason, with several key player developments and performance highlights emerging as they look to reshape their roster for the 2026 MLB season.
Rising Stars on the Hill
In a season marked by ups and downs, the Pirates’ pitching staff garnered attention for its promising rookies. Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson were both recognized in the latest rankings of top MLB rookies, with Ashcraft earning the 26th spot and Mattson coming in at 46th. Ashcraft made a notable debut on May 26 and showcased his potential with a 3.45 ERA over 40 innings pitched, while Mattson excelled in a high-leverage role, finishing the season with a 2.45 ERA in 44 outings. Their performances signal a bright future for the Pirates as they build their rotation.
Arbitration Forecast and Player Decisions
As the offseason approaches, the Pirates have nine players eligible for arbitration, most notably center fielder Oneil Cruz, who is expected to command a significant salary increase. The organization faces critical decisions regarding potential non-tender candidates, and the outcomes of these arbitration cases could significantly impact the team's financial flexibility and roster composition moving forward.
Additionally, the potential departure of veteran Andrew McCutchen looms large, as discussions about his future in Pittsburgh intensify. The Pirates must weigh the value he brings against the need to develop younger talent.
Looking Ahead
With a lackluster finish to the 2025 season, where they ended with a 71-91 record, the Pirates look to the upcoming offseason for a much-needed turnaround. Analysts suggest that addressing the roster through both arbitration decisions and strategic free-agent signings will be crucial if the team hopes to break a decade-long playoff drought.
The Pirates’ Triple-A affiliate, the Indianapolis Indians, had a strong 2025 season, and several prospects will look to make the jump to the majors, further adding to the excitement surrounding the club's future. The upcoming MLB Draft also presents another opportunity for the Pirates to enhance their roster with fresh talent.
TL;DR
- Pittsburgh Pirates rookies Braxton Ashcraft and Isaac Mattson were recognized among the top MLB rookies for their strong performances in 2025.
- Nine players, including Oneil Cruz, are arbitration-eligible, with significant salary increases expected for key contributors.
- The Pirates must make critical roster decisions this offseason to improve on their 71-91 finish and end a decade-long playoff drought.
- The upcoming MLB Draft and the performance of Triple-A prospects will play a crucial role in the team's future direction.