Tigers Facing Tough Decisions on Top Pitching Talent

Skubal Contract Talks Stall as Tigers Balk at Price Tag

The Detroit Tigers are staring down a massive gap in contract negotiations with star left-hander Tarik Skubal, with a reported $250 million separating the two sides. A year ago, the Tigers offered Skubal a mere four-year deal worth less than $100 million, a "noncompetitive" proposal that was quickly rejected.

Now, as Skubal nears free agency after the 2026 season, the Tigers must decide whether to pay up to keep their ace or risk losing him for a late-round draft pick in compensation. Columnist Shawn Windsor argues the Tigers should hold onto Skubal, even if it means losing him to free agency, as his presence gives them the best chance to win next season.

Roster Flexibility Key for Prospect Colt Keith

While the Tigers face a pricey decision on Skubal, they appear to have more flexibility with top prospect Colt Keith. The 22-year-old infielder has proven adept at playing first, second, and third base, allowing the Tigers to keep their options open as they look to build a winning roster around stars like Spencer Torkelson and Riley Greene.

Tigers GM Sam Harris said the team is "breaking through" with Keith's comfort level at multiple positions, giving them "a number of different avenues to build this team" in 2026 and beyond. This positional versatility could prove invaluable as the Tigers navigate a crowded infield picture in the coming years.

TL;DR

  • The Tigers and ace Tarik Skubal are $250 million apart in contract negotiations, putting his long-term future in Detroit in doubt.
  • Prospect Colt Keith's ability to play first, second, and third base gives the Tigers flexibility as they construct their 2026 roster.
  • The Tigers must decide whether to pay up to keep Skubal or risk losing him to free agency after the 2026 season.